Request a quote
Emergency SectorsCareers About us Blog Get in touch
Table with printed charts, a laptop and a hand holding a pen

An electronic signature at work: which level for which document

Adding an electronic signature is easy; the question is what that signature is worth later. European and UK rules recognise three levels, and which one you need depends on the document and on what you may have to prove afterwards. This is how to make that choice, and what IT has to arrange next.

7 min read Written by the ITproposal team
Short answer

eIDAS, and its UK version, recognises three levels: the simple, the advanced and the qualified electronic signature. Only the last one carries the same legal effect as a handwritten signature by default.

The right level follows from the document: what you need to prove later, to whom, and whether the law prescribes a form.

IT handles the rest: how signers are identified, where the signed file ends up, who may send requests and how the evidence is kept. We do not give legal advice.

The three levels of an electronic signature

In everyday speech everything is an electronic signature, from a scanned scribble in a PDF to a signature made with a certificate on a smartcard. The EU eIDAS Regulation, retained in the UK as UK eIDAS alongside the Electronic Communications Act 2000, draws the line with three levels:

  • The simple electronic signature. Any electronic way of showing agreement: a typed name, a tick box, a line drawn on a screen. It cannot be refused legal effect merely because it is electronic, but its evidential weight depends on what you can show around it.
  • The advanced electronic signature. Uniquely linked to the signer, capable of identifying them, created with means under their sole control, and linked to the document so that any later change is detectable.
  • The qualified electronic signature. An advanced signature based on a qualified certificate from a qualified trust service provider, created with a qualified device. It has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature.

Technically, a “digital signature” is something narrower: the cryptographic technique the advanced and qualified levels rely on. When comparing providers, ask which eIDAS level a service delivers rather than relying on the word.

Which level for which document

The question is not “what is most secure” but what will you need to prove later, and to whom. A higher level costs the signer more effort, and a process that is too heavy gets bypassed.

  • Internal approvals and simple orders: a sign-off, a quote a customer accepts, an internal approval. A simple signature is often enough, provided the platform records who signed when.
  • Agreements with consequences: employment contracts, NDAs, purchase and service agreements. Many organisations choose an advanced signature here, because the signer’s identity is then more firmly established.
  • Documents with formal requirements: some documents, such as deeds that need a witness, carry extra formalities that a signing platform does not satisfy on its own. Check those with your solicitor.

Turn it into a table: document type, required level, who may sign. Which level is legally sufficient for a given document is for a lawyer to decide; the table makes sure that decision is then actually applied.

How do you know who signed

The level stands or falls with how the signer is identified. A link in an email only proves that someone had access to that mailbox.

  • Internal signers sign in with their existing work account, with MFA. The signature then ties in with what you already know about that colleague, and access ends the day they leave.
  • External signers get an extra step: a code by text message, an identity check against a document, or a check through a bank or government identity service. The weightier the document, the stronger the step.
  • Qualified signing needs a qualified certificate, which a trust service provider only issues after verifying identity. That takes the signer time the first time; plan for it.

How to set up the accounts and rights underneath is covered under access management with IAM and MFA.

Signature or seal

A signature belongs to a person. For documents your organisation sends out automatically, such as invoices, certificates or statements, eIDAS provides the electronic seal: the same mechanism, but in the name of the legal entity. It proves the document comes from your organisation and has not been altered, without a member of staff signing every copy.

A seal also has advanced and qualified levels. The key question is who controls the certificate: a seal sitting on a server is only as trustworthy as access to that server.

The IT side: integration, rights and shadow IT

Most problems with electronic signing are practical rather than legal. What IT arranges:

  • Sign-in with the existing identity (single sign-on), so no extra passwords appear and leavers lose access automatically.
  • Who may send requests, and on whose behalf. A signature request in the name of the board should not be something anyone can draft.
  • Where the signed document lands: automatically in the case file, document management or HR system, not in the downloads folder of whoever sent it.
  • One platform instead of five. Without an agreement, departments each use their own free service, with contracts scattered across accounts nobody manages.

Evidence and retention: the signed file itself

An electronic signature is only worth something if it can still be checked years later. There are three pitfalls.

  • Keep the signed file, not a copy. A printout or a re-saved PDF loses the signature. Keep the file as it came from the platform, with its audit trail.
  • Certificates expire. A signature that is valid today must still be verifiable in five years. Ask whether the platform embeds a timestamp and the data for long-term validation.
  • Exit. If your signed documents only live on the platform, find out how to get them out when you switch. Ask before you sign up.

Personal data and the trusted list

A signing platform processes names, email addresses, phone numbers and sometimes a copy of an identity document. Under UK GDPR it is a processor, which calls for a data processing agreement covering where the data is held and for how long.

If a service promises qualified signatures, check that the provider appears on the relevant trusted list as a qualified trust service provider for that service: the EU Trusted List for EU qualified status, and the UK trusted list for UK qualified status. Both are public.

Where our work stops

What we do. We make electronic signing work in your environment: sign-in with the existing identity, rights over who sends requests, integrations with document management and other systems, storage and archiving of signed files, and backup. We are ISO/IEC 27001 certified, and that is how we handle that data.

What we do not do. We are not lawyers or solicitors, and we do not say which level is legally sufficient for a given document; have a lawyer decide that. Nor are we a trust service provider: we do not issue certificates or create qualified signatures. The signing platform and the certificates come from a third party.

Frequently asked

Questions we get about this

The five that come up most often.

Is an electronic signature legally binding in the UK?

An electronic signature cannot be refused legal effect simply because it is electronic, and English law generally accepts electronic signatures for contracts. Its evidential weight depends on the level and on what you can show around it. Some documents, such as deeds that need a witness, have extra formalities, so check those with a solicitor.

What is the difference between an electronic and a digital signature?

In everyday use, nothing. Legally, “electronic signature” is the eIDAS term, with three levels. A digital signature is technically the cryptographic method on which the advanced and qualified levels are built.

Is a scanned signature pasted into a PDF an electronic signature?

At most it is a simple electronic signature. An image of a signature is not linked to the signer and does not show later changes, so its evidential weight is limited. For documents with consequences, an advanced or qualified signature is more robust.

Which level of electronic signature do I need?

It depends on the document: what you need to prove later, to whom, and whether the law prescribes a form. For simple approvals a simple signature is often enough; for agreements with consequences many organisations choose an advanced one. Have a lawyer decide what is sufficient for your documents.

Can you provide qualified signatures or legal advice?

No. We are not a trust service provider and not lawyers: certificates and qualified signatures come from a qualified provider, and which level is legally sufficient is for a lawyer to decide. We make signing work in your IT environment: identity, rights, integrations, storage and backup.

Shall we fit signing into your environment?

We look with you at which documents you have signed, how signers are identified today and where signed files end up, and tell you what has to happen technically. The legal level we leave to your lawyer.

Practical IT knowledge in your inbox

New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address for the newsletter only. See our privacy policy.

Request a quote Call