
Email archiving: what to keep, and what to delete on time
Email archiving looks like a setting in Microsoft 365, and that is usually where it goes wrong. An archive has to prove that a message existed and was not changed, find it within a day, and delete it again when the retention period ends. This is what to keep, how to capture every message and the mistakes we see most often when organisations switch.
A backup, the Outlook archive mailbox and an email archive are three different things. Only the last one keeps a message a user has deleted.
An archive is only as complete as what goes into it: capture every message on sending and receipt, including shared mailboxes and leavers.
Deleting is part of the job. Which retention period applies is for your accountant, tax adviser or lawyer to decide; we configure the archive to match.
Email archiving is not the same as a backup
Three things get mixed up in practice, and most organisations that believe they archive their email have one or two of them.
- A backup is a copy for restoring after loss, a mistake or ransomware. It has a short retention period, gets overwritten and is built to bring back a mailbox, not to find one message six years later. Why you arrange that separately for Microsoft 365 is covered in Microsoft 365 backup.
- The Outlook archive mailbox is extra storage for the user. Useful against a full mailbox, but the user can delete from it, so it proves nothing.
- An email archive records every message at the moment it is sent or received, unchanged, searchable and with a retention period.
The question that separates them: can an employee delete a message so that you can no longer find it? If so, you do not have an archive, whatever the setting is called.
What you need to keep, and what you do not
Not every email is a business record. What falls under a retention duty is the correspondence that forms part of your records: a quote, an order confirmation, an agreement on price, an invoice sent as an attachment. The invitation to Friday drinks does not. How long those records must be kept is set by HMRC, company law, your sector regulator or a contract with a client, and the periods differ.
Nobody reviews email message by message. In practice you archive all business email and set a retention period per category: general correspondence, finance, specific departments or mailboxes.
Also record who decides those periods. That is not an IT decision but one for the board, on advice from your accountant or lawyer. IT configures what has been decided and can show that it is set up that way.
How every message gets into the archive
An archive is only as good as what goes into it. There are broadly two ways:
- Capture in transit. The mail platform records a copy of every message on sending and receipt before the user can touch it, through a retention policy on the platform or a journal rule to a separate archive. This is complete, including BCC.
- Collection from mailboxes. The archive reads the mailboxes periodically. Anything that arrives and is deleted between two runs is missed.
Then check that these are covered: sent items, shared mailboxes (info@, accounts@), mailboxes of people who have left, and email from before the archive started, in old PST files or an old mail server. Import those deliberately, or record that the archive counts from a given date.
The simplest test: send a message, delete it straight away from the mailbox and deleted items, and search for it in the archive the next day.
Tamper-proof, and searchable within a day
An archive has to prove two things: that a message has not been altered, and who has searched it.
- Tamper-proof. Nobody, administrators included, can change a message or delete it before the retention period ends.
- Searchable. By sender, recipient, period, text and attachments, across all mailboxes at once. A request from your accountant or solicitor is answered within a day, not a week.
- Access with a reason. Searching someone else’s email is a right for very few people, with a recorded reason. Every search is logged, and a second person reviews sensitive searches.
- Readable for years. The archive exports to an open format with the details intact (sender, date, recipients), so you can open it without the current supplier.
Deleting is part of it
Keeping everything forever feels safe and is not. UK GDPR and the GDPR say you keep personal data no longer than necessary, and an email archive is full of it: names, phone numbers, CVs, sickness notes. When the period ends the archive deletes automatically, and you can show that it did.
The exception is a live dispute or investigation. You place a litigation hold on the mailboxes concerned, so automatic deletion stops there. Lift it when the matter is closed; a hold that stays in place is a retention period nobody chose.
The archive also makes a subject access request answerable. If someone asks what you hold about them, email is part of it, and you need to find it within the statutory deadline.
Where it goes wrong
- PST files. On laptops and network drives, not searchable, fragile once they grow large, and outside any retention period. Collect and import them, or decide they can go.
- The mailbox of a leaver. Deleted to save a licence, and the email goes with it unless the archive already held it. Make this a step in your offboarding, before the account is removed.
- An archive nobody has tested. Run a trial search at least once a year, as if the auditor had just called.
- An old archive server. Installed once, never updated, and the only system holding the email from before the last migration.
- Switching. The archive is the hardest part to move. Ask in advance in what format you get everything back, with the details and the record of who did what, and within what period.
Where our work stops
What we do. We set up the email archive: capture in transit, retention policies in Microsoft 365 or a separate archive, shared mailboxes and leavers included, access and logging, and a trial search that shows it works. When you switch, we make sure you get everything back in a readable format. We are ISO/IEC 27001 certified, which describes how we work, not a verdict on your archive.
What we do not do. We are not tax advisers or lawyers. We do not decide which retention period applies to your organisation, nor whether your archive meets a legal requirement; that is for your accountant, tax adviser or lawyer. Nor are we an auditor, and we certify nothing. We configure what they decide, and show that it is set up that way.
Questions we get about this
The five that come up most often.
How long should a business keep emails?
It depends on what the email is. Correspondence that forms part of your business records, such as quotes, order confirmations and price agreements, falls under the retention periods set by HMRC, company law, your regulator or your contracts. Which period applies to your organisation is for your accountant or lawyer to decide.
Is a backup enough for email archiving?
No. A backup is designed to restore a mailbox and is overwritten after a short period. An archive records every message so it cannot be changed, even if the user deletes it, and keeps it searchable for years. Most organisations need both.
What is the difference between the Outlook archive and email archiving?
The Outlook archive mailbox is extra storage for the user, who can delete from it. Email archiving records messages on sending and receipt so nobody can alter them or delete them early. Only the second can prove that a message existed.
Can we keep all email forever?
Better not. UK GDPR and the GDPR require that personal data is kept no longer than necessary, and email is full of it. Set a period per category, let the archive delete automatically afterwards, and use a litigation hold only for a live dispute or investigation.
Can you tell us which retention period applies to us?
No. We are not tax advisers or lawyers, and we do not decide which period applies or whether your archive meets a legal requirement. That is for your accountant, tax adviser or lawyer. We set up the archive to match what they decide and show that it is configured that way.
Further reading
What the email archive connects to.
Shall we check whether your email is really archived?
Tell us where your email lives now and which retention periods your accountant mentions. We will show what reaches your archive, what falls outside it and how you find it again.
Practical IT knowledge in your inbox
New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.