
Access control systems for business: card, app or PIN
Most people choosing access control systems for business start with the credential: cards, phones or a keypad code. That is the wrong end. What decides the credential is what happens when it is lost, and who gets in then. This is the order we work through it with a client.
A card, an app and a PIN answer the same question three ways: who are you. The difference is what happens when the credential is lost or shared.
Not every card is equally secure. Older cards can be cloned with cheap equipment, and whoever holds the system keys decides whether you can ever change installer.
An access control system is an IT system: it sits on the network, it records who entered where, and it should be tied to the day someone leaves.
The question first, then the credential
An access control system does three things. It establishes who is at the door, decides whether that person may go through that door at that moment, and records that it happened. The credential someone presents, a card, an app or a code, is only the first part.
Three questions drive the choice, and they come before any brochure:
- Who needs to get in where, and when? An office with one entrance and fixed hours is a different problem from a building with a warehouse, a server room and shift work.
- What happens when the credential is lost or passed on? A lost card is blocked with one click; a code everybody knows has to be changed for everybody at once.
- Who maintains the list? If nobody revokes a card on the day someone leaves, it hardly matters how secure that card is.
What we find most often is not a weak card but a list of people who left long ago.
The card: familiar, but not every card is equal
A card or key fob with a chip is still the most common credential, and for good reason: it is quick, needs no battery and everyone understands it. Blocking it when lost takes a mouse click, which is the whole point of access control.
The difference is in the chip. Older cards, often 125 kHz proximity cards, transmit a fixed number without encryption. Readily available equipment can clone them in seconds, sometimes through a bag. Always ask whether the card uses a current encrypted standard and whether the system recognises a cloned card.
Ask who holds the keys as well. Encrypted cards carry a key on the card and in the reader. If only the installer holds that key, you cannot order new cards without them, and you are tied to them the moment you want to switch. Put it in writing that the key belongs to your organisation.
What drives the cost of a card system is not the cards but the number of doors, whether they work online or offline, and how much cabling has to reach each one.
The app on the phone
With a mobile credential the phone identifies itself to the reader over NFC or Bluetooth. No cards to hand out, access revoked remotely, and a new starter can get in on day one without stopping at reception.
The strongest argument is the phone itself. It is already locked with a PIN, fingerprint or face. If the app asks for the phone to be unlocked before it opens the door, you have two factors without anyone carrying a second thing.
Three things to settle beforehand:
- The flat battery. Some phones still open doors for a while after shutting down; do not rely on it, and keep a fallback.
- The personal phone. Can you ask staff to install an app on their own device? That is an agreement rather than a technology, and anyone without a suitable phone still needs a card.
- Device management. On company phones the app belongs in device management, so it disappears when the person leaves.
The PIN: cheap at first, costly in practice
A keypad is quick to fit and asks nothing of the user. The problem is that a code is not a person. Within months the cleaner knows it, the courier, the former intern and anyone who ever looked over a shoulder.
- You do not know who came in, only that someone knew the code. For an audit trail that means anything, a shared code is worthless.
- Changing it means telling everyone. Once that is too much effort, it stops happening.
- Strong as a second step. A card plus a personal PIN for the server room is a good combination: a found card on its own is not enough.
A code per person solves the first problem, but then you are maintaining a list just as with cards, with a better chance of a code on a sticky note by the door.
Planning access control systems for business door by door
Most buildings do not need one credential but a plan. Start with the doors and give each one a level:
- Main entrance: card or app, single factor during working hours, possibly with a code on top outside them.
- Server room and archive: card plus PIN, a small group with access, every visit recorded.
- Warehouse and loading door: often shifts and suppliers; time windows per group rather than one list.
- Visitors: temporary access that expires by itself, or a video door intercom that reception opens remotely.
Write down as well what happens when power or the network fails. Readers that keep working offline with the last known list, a door that releases or stays locked: those are choices, and on a fire exit it is not an IT choice. More on the technology behind it is on our page on video surveillance and access control.
It is an IT system, so manage it like one
Readers, controllers and management software sit on the network and need updates. Put them on their own network segment, so a door controller never becomes a route to your office files, and give the admin account its own password and multi-factor authentication.
Tie it to the leavers process. The best access control is linked to the same list that creates and removes user accounts, so a departure is handled in one place. How that works for accounts is on our page on identity and access management; a door belongs in the same step.
The log contains personal data. Who came in when says something about people. Agree a retention period, limit who can see it and record why. Biometrics, a fingerprint or face at the door, are special category data under the UK GDPR, and the ICO expects you to justify them carefully. Get legal advice before you buy. Where staff are represented, the system belongs on that agenda too.
Where our work stops
What we do. We help decide which door gets which credential, supply and install the readers and the system, connect it to your network and to the joiners and leavers process, and manage it afterwards: updates, issuing and revoking cards and apps, and the log with an agreed retention period.
What we do not do. We do not sit in the monitoring centre. Watching live, responding to alarms and sending someone to site is work for a licensed security company; if you want that as well, we agree with such a party who picks up what. Nor do we decide how a fire exit behaves when the power fails: that is fire safety, and belongs to the door hardware installer and your fire safety adviser. Whether biometrics or a log is lawful in your situation is a legal judgement we do not give.
Questions we get about this
The five that come up most often.
What is an access control system?
A system that establishes who is at a door, decides whether that person may enter at that moment and records that it happened. The credential can be a card, a phone app, a PIN or a combination. Unlike a key, access can be revoked remotely and you can see afterwards who came in.
Is a card or a phone app more secure?
An app on a locked phone can be more secure, because unlocking the phone adds a second factor. A modern encrypted card is fine too; an old 125 kHz proximity card is not. In practice security depends more on revoking access when people leave than on the credential itself.
Can an access card be cloned?
Older cards without encryption can, with readily available equipment and in seconds. Cards using a current encrypted standard are much harder to clone, provided the keys are properly managed. Ask your supplier which card you have and whether the system detects a copy.
Can we use fingerprints for door access?
Biometric data is special category data under the UK GDPR, so you need a clear justification and the right safeguards, and the ICO publishes guidance on it. Get legal advice before you buy such a system. We do not give a view on whether it is lawful in your case.
Do you also respond to alarms?
No. We select, install and manage the access control system, but we do not sit in the monitoring centre. Responding to alarms and sending someone to site is work for a licensed security company. We agree with such a party who does what.
Further reading
What access control connects to.
Which door gets which credential?
Send us the floor plan and who needs to get in where. We propose a plan per door, and say what happens in a power cut and how leavers are handled.
Practical IT knowledge in your inbox
New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.