Request a quote
Emergency SectorsCareers About us Blog Get in touch
Technician working on the cabling inside a server cabinet

Tape backup: when LTO still makes sense

Tape backup sounds like something from another era, yet plenty of server rooms still have a tape drive. Sometimes rightly so: a tape taken out of the drive is out of an attacker’s reach, and for large volumes of data that must be kept for years, little scales as well. But tape only works if someone keeps it going, and that is usually where it fails.

6 min read Written by the ITproposal team
Short answer

Tape fits large data volumes, long retention and the need for a copy that is genuinely offline. In a small environment with nobody to swap tapes, immutable off-site storage usually wins.

A tape is only offline when it is out of the drive and out of the library. A tape left sitting in a slot is as reachable as a disk.

The two biggest risks are a rotation that quietly stops and data you can no longer read years later because the drive for that generation is gone.

When tape backup is still the right choice

Tape backup is one way to meet the extra offline copy in the 3-2-1 backup rule. It is not the only one, and for many offices not the easiest. Tape fits mainly when several of these four apply at once:

  • Lots of data. Tens of terabytes or more: drawings, video, measurement data. The larger the volume, the better tape scales: you add a cartridge, not a system.
  • Long retention. Archives that must be kept for years and are rarely opened.
  • A copy that must be physically separate. Because your policy, an insurer or a customer asks for it, or because you do not want everything to hinge on one password.
  • A slow link to the outside world. Sending a full copy of tens of terabytes to the cloud over a business line can take days; a tape goes in a bag.

If none of the four applies, and nobody swaps tapes every week, immutable off-site storage is usually the better choice. It does the same job without anyone having to take something home on a Friday; see our article on immutable backup.

What a tape outside the drive protects, and what it does not

The strongest case for tape is the air gap: a cartridge on a shelf cannot be encrypted, wiped or overwritten by someone inside your network. The NCSC also advises keeping at least one backup offline. Three caveats separate a real air gap from a feeling of safety:

  • A tape in the library is online. An autoloader with eight slots in which every tape stays put is, for an attacker with admin rights, just a slow disk. Offline means out, and somewhere else.
  • Encryption without key management is a second disaster. LTO drives encrypt in hardware, and that should be on for tapes that leave the building. But lose the key and the tape is unreadable, to you as well. Keep the keys apart from the tapes and from the system that writes them.
  • WORM cartridges can be written only once. Useful for archives that must provably stay unchanged, not for a daily rotation.

Standalone drive, autoloader or library

  • A standalone drive, internal or external. Someone swaps every tape by hand. Fine if the full backup fits on one or two cartridges.
  • An autoloader: one drive with a handful of slots. The backup software swaps tapes itself; a person periodically removes the ones that go off site.
  • A tape library: several drives and tens to hundreds of slots, for large environments and long archives.

Two things go with every option. The backup software must support the drive, including its generation and encryption; check the compatibility list before you order. And the drive must be fed fast enough. Tape writes in a steady stream; if data arrives too slowly, the drive keeps stopping and starting, which is slower and causes wear. A fast disk tier where the backup lands first and then goes to tape solves that.

A rotation someone keeps up

Tape rarely fails on technology and often on people. A rotation that runs well for three months and then stops because the person who swaps tapes is on leave leaves you with a cupboard of old tapes and no recent offline copy.

  • Choose a simple scheme. The classic grandfather-father-son (daily, weekly, monthly) is clear and easy to sustain. Keep the monthly tapes longer than the weekly ones.
  • Record who swaps tapes, and who covers. By name, not by job title.
  • Let the software warn you when an expected tape was not swapped or a job failed, to a shared mailbox rather than one person.
  • Keep tapes outside the building, at a second site or in a fire-resistant safe elsewhere, cool, dry and in their cases. A tape next to the server burns with it.
  • Label and register every cartridge: what is on it, when it was written and how long it is kept.

Generations and long-term readability

Every few years a new LTO generation appears with more capacity. A new drive, however, reads only a limited number of older generations, often one or two, and recent generations have narrowed that further. If you need to open an archive in ten years, think about it now.

  • Keep a working drive for every generation you still need, with the software that drives it, or plan a migration to newer tapes before the last old drive goes.
  • Mind your retention obligations. HMRC expects records to be kept and to be produced on request. A tape with no drive to read it does not meet that.
  • Consider LTFS for archives. With that open format the contents sit on tape as ordinary files, so reading them back does not depend on a single backup product.

Restoring from tape: what makes it slow

Tape is sequential: to reach a file, the drive winds to where it sits. A full restore of a whole server therefore runs reasonably well, but finding one folder from three weeks ago can take a long time, especially if the tape first has to come back from another site.

That is why tape is almost never your first route to recovery. Use a copy on disk for everyday restores and keep tape for the day everything else has been hit. Test restoring from tape separately, with a tape that genuinely sat outside the building, and record how long it took from the moment someone went to fetch it. That figure belongs in your recovery plan, not an estimate.

What drives the cost of tape

Tape has a reputation for being cheap per terabyte, and for large volumes that is often true. But the sum involves more than cartridges. What really drives the cost:

  • The drive or library and its maintenance contract.
  • The number of cartridges, which follows from your data volume multiplied by the number of generations you keep.
  • The licence for the backup software’s tape support, if it is charged separately.
  • People’s time: swapping, transporting, registering and testing, every week.
  • Off-site storage and getting tapes there.
  • The migration to a new generation, a few years down the line.

Put that sum next to immutable off-site storage, where mainly the storage itself and the connection count. For small volumes the comparison usually goes against tape; for large archives it often goes in its favour.

Where our work stops

What we do. We advise whether tape suits you, supply and install drives, autoloaders and libraries, configure the backup software and encryption, draw up a rotation scheme and test restores with you.

What we do not do. How long you are legally required to keep data, and how you handle erasure requests under UK GDPR for data sitting on tape, is not ours to decide. That is a question for your accountant, your solicitor or your data protection officer. We configure the retention you set. And how long a cartridge lasts is a manufacturer’s claim under its own storage conditions; we do not vouch for it.

Frequently asked

Questions we get about this

The five that come up most often.

Is tape backup still relevant?

For large data volumes, long retention and a copy that must be genuinely offline, yes. A tape removed from the drive is out of an attacker’s reach. For a small environment with nobody to swap tapes, immutable off-site storage is usually more practical.

Is a tape in an autoloader offline?

No. As long as the tape sits in a slot of the autoloader or library, software with admin rights can reach it, and so can wipe or overwrite it. A tape is only offline once it has been removed from the device and is kept outside the building.

Can a new LTO drive read old tapes?

Only a limited number of generations back, often one or two, and fewer with recent generations. Check compatibility before you retire an old drive. If archives must stay readable for a long time, keep a working old drive or migrate the data to newer tapes in time.

How often should tapes be rotated?

That follows from how much data you are prepared to lose. A common scheme is daily, weekly and monthly, with at least the weekly and monthly tapes kept off site. More important than the scheme is a named person responsible, with a deputy.

Do you decide how long we keep tapes?

No. The legal retention period and handling erasure requests under UK GDPR are questions for your accountant, solicitor or data protection officer. We set up the rotation and retention you decide on, and make sure the tapes stay readable for that period.

Related services

Further reading

What tape connects to.

Shall we check whether tape suits you?

Tell us how much data you have, how long you must keep it and who checks the backup today. We will say whether tape, immutable storage or a combination works best.

Practical IT knowledge in your inbox

New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address for the newsletter only. See our privacy policy.

Request a quote Call