Request a quote
Emergency SectorsCareers About us Blog Get in touch
Headset on a desk in front of a monitor showing chat windows

Shared mailbox, group or distribution list: which one to use for info@

For an address such as info@ or accounts@, Microsoft 365 offers three options, and they look alike until a customer is waiting for a reply. A shared mailbox keeps, a distribution list forwards, and a group does a little of both. The deciding question is not technical: does someone need to reply to this email, and do the others need to see that they did?

7 min read Written by the ITproposal team
Short answer

An address that customers write to should be a shared mailbox: the history stays with the address, not with the person.

A distribution list is for messages everyone must see and nobody answers on the group’s behalf.

Grant access through groups, set Send As deliberately and decide in advance where sent items end up.

Shared mailbox, group and distribution list: what each does

All three have an address and look much the same in the address book. The difference lies in what happens to a message once it arrives:

  • A shared mailbox is one mailbox that several people work in. Each message arrives once, everyone can see what has been read, moved and answered, and replies go out from the shared address. Nobody signs in to it with a password of its own; access runs through each member of staff’s own account.
  • A distribution list has no mailbox. A message to the address is forwarded to every member, each of whom gets their own copy. Whoever replies does so from their own address, and the others cannot see it.
  • A Microsoft 365 group has a shared mailbox for conversations, plus a calendar, a SharePoint site and optionally a team in Teams. Members read conversations in the group or have them delivered to their own inbox.

Google Workspace has the same split under other names: a Google Group as a mailing list or as a collaborative inbox, and delegated access to a mailbox. The deciding question below applies there just the same.

The deciding question: does someone need to reply?

Start with what needs to happen to the email, not with the technology:

  • Someone must reply, and the others must see that it has been done: a shared mailbox. That covers info@, sales@, accounts@ and bookings@.
  • Everyone needs to know and nobody replies on the group’s behalf: a distribution list. Think all staff, all branch managers, or an alert from a system that three people need to see.
  • A team works together on more than email, with a shared calendar and files: a Microsoft 365 group, usually through Teams.

The mistake we see most is info@ set up as a distribution list. Five people receive the same enquiry, two reply or nobody does, and once someone leaves there is no way of telling what was promised. An address customers write to should be a shared mailbox, because the history stays with the address rather than the person.

How we set up a shared mailbox for info@

A shared mailbox takes minutes to create. What makes it usable is the arrangement around it:

  • Access through a group, not person by person. Whoever joins the team gets the mailbox; whoever leaves loses it, without anyone having to remember.
  • Folders or categories for status: new, in progress, waiting for customer, done. A colleague covering for someone sees at a glance what is open.
  • An owner who decides who gets access and makes sure nothing sits unanswered during the holidays.
  • An automatic reply telling the sender what to expect, and a signature that names the address, not the person.

If another system sends as info@, such as a newsletter service or the accounting package, sort out sender authentication for the domain as well. Otherwise those messages land in the recipient’s spam; our article on SPF, DKIM and DMARC explains how it works.

Full Access, Send As, Send on Behalf

On a shared mailbox you set three permissions per group or person, and they are often confused:

  • Full Access: read, move and delete. On its own it does not let anyone send as the mailbox.
  • Send As: the message comes from info@ without the recipient seeing who wrote it. This is usually what you want.
  • Send on Behalf: the recipient sees “Sam on behalf of info@”. Useful when the person needs to be visible, such as an assistant writing for a director.

Watch where sent items are kept. Depending on how Outlook opens the mailbox, a reply from the shared address often lands in the sender’s own Sent Items rather than the mailbox’s. The others then cannot see what was answered. Microsoft 365 lets you change that, and it belongs in the setup, not in the response to the first complaint.

What goes wrong with a shared mailbox

  • Info@ as an ordinary account with a shared password. Nobody knows who did what, multi-factor authentication cannot work per person, and the password stays valid for everyone who leaves. Convert such an account into a shared mailbox.
  • No licence when it needs one. A shared mailbox does not need a licence of its own up to a certain size. Once it grows beyond that, or you want an archive or a retention policy on it, it does. Check before the mailbox fills up.
  • Rules in your own Outlook. A rule that moves mail out of the shared mailbox then only runs while your Outlook is open. Rules belong on the mailbox itself.
  • A distribution list that rejects outside mail. On a new list, receiving from external senders is often switched off by default. A supplier writing to it gets a bounce, and nobody inside notices.
  • Automatic forwarding to a personal address. Anyone forwarding mail from a list or mailbox to their own address outside the company takes business email outside your security. Switch off automatic external forwarding unless there is a decision to allow it.

When someone leaves: converting their mailbox

A shared mailbox solves another problem too: the mailbox of a colleague who has left. Rather than leaving the account open with a password somebody knows, you convert the mailbox to a shared mailbox, give their successor or manager access and set an automatic reply with the new address. The account itself can then be blocked and, depending on size, the licence is freed up.

Two things go with it. Agree a period after which the mailbox is archived or deleted under your retention policy. And decide in advance who may look inside: an employee’s mailbox also contains personal messages. What a manager may open is a question of UK GDPR and employment law, not of technology; the ICO’s guidance on monitoring workers is a sensible starting point for your adviser.

When a shared mailbox is no longer enough

A shared mailbox works well as long as a small team can keep track of the mail. It starts to strain when:

  • more arrives than can be cleared in a day, and nobody knows any more what has been picked up;
  • you want to measure how quickly replies go out, or have agreed response times;
  • several channels come together, such as email, chat and phone.

That is when a ticketing system or customer service platform is the next step: every enquiry gets a number, an owner and a status. Our article on choosing a helpdesk ticketing system covers how to pick one. Those platforms usually read from the shared mailbox, so the setup above is not wasted work.

Where our work stops

What we do. We set up shared mailboxes, groups and distribution lists in Microsoft 365, with access through groups, the right send permissions, rules on the mailbox, sender authentication for the domain and a fixed procedure for leavers. It is part of how we manage Microsoft 365.

What we do not do. We are not lawyers. Whether and when a manager may open the mailbox of a current or former employee, and how long email must be kept, is for your solicitor or data protection officer to judge; we carry out what you decide. And a customer service or CRM platform belongs to a third party: we connect it to the mailbox, while the platform itself and the way your customer service runs in it are that supplier’s.

Frequently asked

Questions we are asked about this

The five that come up most often.

What is the difference between a shared mailbox and a distribution list?

A shared mailbox is one mailbox that several people work in: everyone sees the same messages and what has happened to them, and replies go out from the shared address. A distribution list has no mailbox; it forwards each message to its members, who each get their own copy and reply from their own address.

Does a shared mailbox need a licence?

In Microsoft 365 usually not, as long as the mailbox stays under the storage limit and you do not put an archive or retention policy on it. Users open it with their own account and licence. If the mailbox grows or you need more features, a licence is required; check before it fills up.

How do I add a shared mailbox in Outlook?

If an administrator has given you Full Access, the mailbox usually appears in Outlook by itself after a while. If it does not, add it as an additional mailbox through your account settings. To send from the shared address you also need the Send As or Send on Behalf permission.

Is a Microsoft 365 group better than a shared mailbox?

For a team that also shares a calendar, files and Teams, often yes. For an address customers write to, where replies must come from that address, a shared mailbox usually works better, because the status of each message stays visible and send permissions are simpler.

Can a manager open the mailbox of an employee who has left?

That is a legal question rather than a technical one, and we do not judge it. Technically the mailbox can be converted into a shared mailbox with access for the successor. What may be opened and how long it is kept should be agreed in advance with your solicitor or data protection officer.

Related services

Further reading

What else comes with shared email.

Shall we review your shared addresses?

Send us the list of addresses such as info@ and accounts@ that you use today. We will tell you which option fits each one and what is missing in permissions and rules.

Practical IT knowledge in your inbox

New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address for the newsletter only. See our privacy policy.

Request a quote Call