
An IT supplier review: the points that matter, once a year
Most organisations assess an IT supplier once: when they choose it. After that the contract rolls on and the only test is whether anyone complains. This is the list for an annual IT supplier review, built on evidence rather than impressions. It was written by an IT supplier, so use it on us as well.
A supplier review is only worth something if it returns to the same points every year. Then you see the direction, not just today’s position.
Assess on evidence you can request yourself: figures from the ticketing system, a valid certificate with the right scope, current documentation. Measure user satisfaction separately.
The judgement is yours. A supplier can provide the figures, but it cannot review itself, and a competitor cannot do it either.
Why an IT supplier review, and why every year
Most IT contracts renew automatically. That is fine as long as someone has checked, before that date, whether the commitments are being met. Without a fixed review it only happens after a major outage, and then the judgement is coloured by that one bad week.
There are three reasons to do it annually, and they reinforce each other:
- The renewal. The moment you can change anything is fixed in the contract. Schedule the review a few months before it, so there is time for an improvement plan or a move.
- The standard. If you work to ISO 9001 or ISO/IEC 27001, your auditor expects you to monitor and re-evaluate suppliers. NIS2 also asks organisations in scope to address the security of their supply chain.
- The direction. One review tells you where things stand. Three on the same points tell you whether it is improving or getting worse, and that is what you want to know at renewal.
The points that matter
Keep it to seven points. More becomes a questionnaire nobody completes; fewer leaves out exactly the part where the problems are.
- Commitments met. Response and resolution times from the SLA, measured from the point the contract defines. How to write commitments that are achievable is covered in SLAs you can actually meet.
- Quality of fixes. How many tickets are reopened after closure, and which problems are still there after a year?
- Security. Is the certificate still valid, and does the service you buy fall within its scope? Were incidents affecting you reported on time?
- Continuity. Does your environment depend on one person at the supplier? Which subcontractors are involved, and do you know?
- Ownership and exit readiness. Are admin accounts, licences and the domain name in your name, and is the documentation current? This is the point that decides how free you are at renewal.
- Initiative. Does the supplier bring improvements of its own, or only answers to tickets?
- Invoices. Do they match the contract, and was extra work approved in advance by someone entitled to approve it?
Review on evidence, not impressions
A supplier review based on impressions mostly measures the last month. For each point, record where the evidence comes from, and request it before the meeting.
- From the ticketing system: volumes per month, targets met and missed, reopened tickets. Ask for the raw export, not just the chart.
- From the supplier: the certificate and its scope, a list of subcontractors, the date the documentation was last updated.
- From your own records: invoices, approved extra work, the list of what was requested this year and not delivered.
- From users: a short question to a handful of colleagues across departments. Keep this separate from the figures; satisfaction and delivery are two different things.
A single spot check often says more than a report: ask for a password from the vault, or have a file restored from backup. How long that takes is an answer to the question about exit readiness.
A score you can read back next year
Give each point a simple score, for example on a scale of one to four, and add one sentence on why. That sentence matters more than the number: next year nobody will remember why it was a three.
- Use an even scale. With five steps everyone picks the middle, and the middle says nothing.
- Weight in advance, not afterwards. Decide before the review which points count more. For a managed service provider with access to everything, security weighs more than initiative.
- Set a floor. A score below the agreed threshold on security or ownership triggers an improvement plan, however good the rest is.
- Keep one document per year. Same points, same order. Then the direction sits side by side.
The meeting with your supplier
Send the review in advance. A supplier that sees its scores for the first time in the meeting spends the hour defending instead of fixing.
An agenda that works: the scores with their explanation, the two or three points that matter most, what the supplier itself sees coming, and actions. Each action gets an owner and a date, and comes back at the next quarterly review.
Agree beforehand what the outcome can be: continue, continue with an improvement plan, or prepare to move. If it is the last, the review is your starting point; how such a move works is described in changing IT supplier without damage.
ISO 27001 and ISO 9001: what an auditor wants to see
Neither standard prescribes a form. Both ask whether you do it, and whether you can show it.
- ISO 9001 requires in clause 8.4 that you set criteria for the evaluation, selection, performance monitoring and re-evaluation of external providers, and that you retain the results.
- ISO/IEC 27001 has a group of controls on supplier relationships in Annex A of the 2022 edition. Control 5.22 covers monitoring, reviewing and managing changes to supplier services.
So what an auditor wants to see: the criteria on paper, a review that actually took place, and actions that were followed up. A completed checklist with nothing after it is exactly what gets noted as a weakness. A review on the seven points above covers the ordinary case; whether it is enough for your certification is for your own auditor to decide.
Where our work stops
What we do. We are an IT supplier ourselves and provide the figures that belong to these points: reporting from the ticketing system, our certificate with its scope, documentation and admin accounts in the client’s name. Within service governance we put the figures of all suppliers side by side using one definition, including parties that are not us, and report on our own performance in the same way.
What we do not do. We are not an independent procurement adviser. We give no verdict on another supplier, we do not evaluate other parties’ bids and we do not tell you whom to stay with. The judgement and the decision are yours. If you want an independent review, use a party that does not supply. Nor are we a certifying auditor: whether your supplier management meets ISO 27001 or ISO 9001 is determined by the certification body.
Questions we get about this
The five that come up most often.
What is a supplier review?
A fixed, recurring check of whether a supplier meets its commitments: service, quality, security, continuity, ownership of data and invoicing. It is different from the selection at the start; a supplier review looks at what was actually delivered during the contract.
How often should you review an IT supplier?
Once a year is enough for most organisations, scheduled a few months before the renewal date. Alongside it there should be a shorter quarterly meeting where the actions from the review come back. After a major incident an extra review makes sense.
What criteria should a supplier performance review use?
For an IT supplier, seven points work: SLA delivery, quality of fixes, security, continuity, ownership and exit readiness, initiative and invoicing. Give each a score with one sentence of explanation, and decide in advance which points carry more weight.
Does ISO 27001 require supplier reviews?
A certified organisation must show that it monitors and reviews supplier services; in Annex A of ISO/IEC 27001:2022 this is control 5.22. ISO 9001 asks in clause 8.4 for documented criteria for re-evaluation. How you set it up is up to you, as long as it is carried out and followed up.
Can you review our other IT suppliers?
No. We are an IT supplier ourselves, so we give no verdict on other suppliers and do not evaluate other parties’ bids. What we do, within service governance, is put the figures of all suppliers side by side using one definition, including our own. The judgement stays with you.
Further reading
What this review connects to.
Want to review us on these points?
Ask for the figures behind each point, even if you are not yet a client. We provide them; the judgement is yours.
Practical IT knowledge in your inbox
New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.