
Electronic shelf labels: when the business case adds up
Electronic shelf labels are sold with a demonstration: one click and a thousand prices change at once. The business case rests on something duller: how many hours repricing costs you now, how often the shelf edge and the till disagree, and what the investment is per shelf position. This article sets out which lines belong in it, how to measure them before you ask for a quote and where the sum usually tips over.
A business case for electronic shelf labels rests on the work that disappears and the errors that drop away, not on what becomes newly possible.
Measure it beforehand in two stores: how often prices change, how long a repricing round takes and how often shelf and till disagree. Without that baseline, any payback period is a guess.
Changing prices more often is technically possible at once, but pricing rules and your own price process decide how far you go. The label corrects nothing.
Electronic shelf labels: when the business case adds up
The sum has three columns, and they do not carry equal weight. What it costs: the labels, the infrastructure, the software, the integration and the rollout. What disappears: repricing with paper, the printing, and the gaps between shelf edge and till that now produce complaints and corrections. What becomes possible: marking down more often and faster, order picking with a flashing label, information at the shelf that does not fit on paper today.
The business case adds up when the second column covers the first. The third column is upside, but do not count on it: what becomes possible only happens once someone organises the work, and that is in no quote.
A rule of thumb that nearly always holds: electronic shelf labels pay off with many items and prices that move often, as in supermarkets, chemists, DIY and electronics. In a shop with a fixed range that changes price a few times a year, the sum rarely works.
What sits on the cost side
Most of the investment sits in the number of shelf positions, not in the system around them. So count positions first, not products; an item displayed in two places needs two labels. What else belongs in it:
- The labels themselves, per size. A larger label with more information costs more than the smallest one that shows the price.
- Holders and rails. Do they fit the shelf strips you have, or do those need replacing too? In an older store that is a line of its own.
- Access points or base stations in the ceiling, with power and a network connection. The number follows from floor area and layout, and that is a measurement.
- The software, often a subscription per label or per store. Ask what happens if you cancel it.
- The integration with your pricing or till system. Built once, then maintained with every update on either side.
- The rollout: fitting labels and linking each to the right product in a store that stays open.
- Replacement: labels that break, go missing or run out of battery, and the spare stock you keep for that.
Ask every supplier for these lines separately, and compare over the whole lifetime rather than the purchase.
What disappears, and how to count it
The return that carries a business case is work that stops and errors that drop away. Both can be counted, and they should be, because this is where the sum is most often stretched.
- Repricing. The number of price changes a week, times the time per ticket: printing, finding, swapping, throwing the old one away. Use what it really costs, including the changes that currently get left undone.
- Printing. Paper, ink and the printers in store. A small line, but one that disappears entirely.
- Gaps between shelf and till. Every customer charged a different price at the till costs a correction, a conversation and sometimes a refund. Count how often that happens now, not how often you think it does.
- Checking. The round in which someone checks the tickets are right. It shrinks, but does not disappear.
Be strict about that last one: a label that is badly fitted or linked to the wrong product still shows a wrong price. Part of the work shifts from swapping to checking.
What becomes possible, and why you keep it separate
Electronic shelf labels can do more than show prices, and that is where the best parts of every demonstration sit. Keep them out of the sum that has to justify the investment, and only count them once someone is responsible for delivering them.
- Marking down more often. Fresh products reduced at the end of the day, or an offer that starts in the afternoon. That cuts waste, but only if someone writes and polices the rules.
- Order picking. A label that flashes at the item a colleague has to pick for an online order. It works well, and needs an integration with your order system.
- Information at the shelf. Origin, a quality mark, a stock level, a code the customer scans. What fits depends on what your systems know.
These are reasons to choose a system that can do it. They are not reasons to buy if the second column does not cover the first.
Measure it before the quote, and agree the trial in advance
A payback period from a brochure is an average of stores that are not yours. So measure for yourself, in two stores that differ, for a few weeks:
- The number of shelf positions per store, and how many have an unusual size or an awkward spot.
- The number of price changes a week, including promotions and markdowns.
- The time per repricing round, measured, not estimated.
- The number of shelf and till mismatches, from a spot check on a fixed set of items.
Then run a trial in one store, and agree in advance when it counts as a success: how much less time goes on repricing, how many fewer mismatches there are, and how often a label was wrong. A trial without criteria always ends in “it works well”, and that says nothing about the sum.
What the technology involves, from base stations to shelf rails, is on our page about electronic shelf labels.
Changing prices more often: what the rules require
Technically you can change a price every hour. Legally and commercially it is different, and that boundary belongs in the business case, because it decides how much of the third column you can really use.
- Price reductions. In the UK, a reference price in a reduction must not mislead under consumer protection law, and trading standards look at how long the higher price really applied. In Ireland and the rest of the EU, the Omnibus Directive requires the earlier price in a reduction to be the lowest price of the previous thirty days. If you change often, you need that history per product.
- Unit pricing. In the UK the Price Marking Order 2004 requires a price per kilo or per litre for many goods, and EU rules do the same. Choose a label size on which that fits legibly.
- Trust. A customer who sees a price go up between morning and afternoon remembers it. That is not law, but it is a limit.
What these rules mean for your promotions is for your lawyer or trade association to assess. We are not lawyers; we make sure the system keeps the data you need for it.
The process behind the label
Electronic shelf labels make a mistake in the pricing system bigger, not smaller: a wrong price then shows in every branch at once, and because it is the same everywhere, nobody notices. The business case is only complete with a few agreements about who may do what.
- Who changes a price, and who checks a large change before it goes to every store.
- One store first. A new promotion or a large repricing round goes to one branch first and only then to the rest.
- A log of every change, with time and name. You also need it for the thirty days above.
- What happens during an outage. A label shows the last price it received. If the integration drops, someone has to know which changes did not arrive.
- Who replaces labels that are broken or missing, and how quickly.
Where our work stops
What we do. We supply the labels, holders and base stations, measure coverage, connect the base stations to their own network segment and roll the labels out per branch, including linking each to the right product. We connect the label platform to your pricing or till system and make sure it gets clean data. On site, our own local engineers do that, in every country.
What we do not do. The pricing system, the till software and the label platform belong to third parties, and the prices in them are yours. We do not set prices, design promotions or make advertising, and we do not correct prices at source. We are not lawyers and do not assess whether a price reduction complies with the rules. If the price in the system is wrong, no label will fix it.
Questions we get about this
The five that come up most often.
When do electronic shelf labels pay for themselves?
Usually with many shelf positions and prices that change often, as in supermarkets, chemists, DIY and electronics. The business case adds up when the repricing work, printing and shelf and till mismatches that disappear cover the investment. With a fixed range and few price changes, the sum rarely works.
What drives the cost of electronic shelf labels?
Mainly the number of shelf positions, because there is one label per position. Then the sizes, holders and rails, the number of base stations, the software, the integration with the pricing or till system, the rollout and replacing labels that break. Compare over the whole lifetime, not just the purchase.
How long does an electronic shelf label battery last?
E-paper only uses power when the image changes, so a label typically runs for years on one battery. How often you change prices and whether the label flashes or lights up both make a difference. Ask the supplier for the lifetime at your number of changes and what replacement involves.
Can you change prices often with electronic shelf labels?
Technically yes, but a reference price in a reduction must not mislead, and in the EU it has to be the lowest price of the previous thirty days; many goods also need a unit price. If you change often, you need that history per product. Have your lawyer or trade association assess what it means for your promotions.
Do you also set the prices on the labels?
No. The pricing system and till software belong to third parties and the prices are yours. We supply and install the labels and base stations, connect the platform to your system and make sure it gets clean data. We do not set prices, design promotions or correct prices at source.
Further reading
What a shelf label connects to.
Count first, then buy labels
Tell us how many shelf positions and branches are involved, how often you change prices and which pricing system you use. We will say what comes with it in labels, base stations, network and rollout; the prices and the sum stay yours.
Practical IT knowledge in your inbox
New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.