Request a quote
Emergency SectorsCareers About us Blog Get in touch
Two colleagues at a whiteboard covered in technical diagrams in a glass-walled meeting room

VMware alternatives after Broadcom: Proxmox, Hyper-V or Nutanix, and how to plan the move

Since the Broadcom acquisition, VMware is back on the agenda for many organisations, usually at the next renewal. Choosing between VMware alternatives is less about the best product than about what you use from VMware today and how much of it you would have to replace. This is the order in which we compare Proxmox vs VMware, Hyper-V and Nutanix, and plan the migration.

7 min read Written by the ITproposal team
Short answer

The moment to decide is the renewal, and the first question is which VMware features you really use. Every feature you rely on, the alternative has to provide as well.

Proxmox, Hyper-V and Nutanix are all mature, but they need different skills, different backup software and sometimes different hardware. Staying on VMware is a valid outcome too.

A migration runs in waves, starts with a pilot and keeps a way back for every virtual machine. The software, the licence terms and the vendor support remain the manufacturer’s.

What has changed since Broadcom, and what has not

Broadcom acquired VMware and rebuilt the offering: no more standalone products and perpetual licences, but subscriptions in a small number of large bundles. If you used one component, the renewal brings a bundle with more in it, on a different model from the one you originally signed up to. Our page on Broadcom sets out what that means in practice if you already run VMware.

What has not changed is the software itself. vSphere runs today as it did last year. There is no technical reason to leave in a hurry, and a commercial reason to know what you want well before the next renewal. Organisations that start looking three months ahead usually renew, because a migration cannot be done carefully in that time.

So put the end date of your current support in the diary and work backwards: inventory, a pilot, the migration in waves and a period in which the old platform still runs alongside the new one. That is closer to a year than a quarter.

Start with what you actually use from VMware

Most environments use only part of what they have, and that part decides which of the VMware alternatives fits. Go through this list and note for each line whether you use it, and for what:

  • Live migration and high availability. Moving virtual machines without interruption, and restarting them automatically on another host when one fails. Every serious alternative does this; the question is how it works with your storage.
  • Automatic load balancing. Virtual machines moving to a quieter host on their own. That works differently or more simply elsewhere. Check whether you actually rely on it or merely have it switched on.
  • Storage. A SAN or NAS the hosts connect to, or vSAN. In the first case you can often keep the storage; in the second you are replacing your storage layer too.
  • Networking. Standard virtual switches, distributed switches or NSX. The further along that list, the bigger the job.
  • What connects to it. Backup software, monitoring, replication to a second site, scripts and templates. All of them have to support the new platform, and this is where migrations most often slip.

Also note which virtual machines a vendor delivered as a ready-made appliance. Some are only supported on VMware, and then it is the vendor of that software who decides whether it can move.

Proxmox vs VMware: where the difference lies

Proxmox VE is open source and built on KVM, the hypervisor that is part of Linux itself. Management runs in a web interface, and clustering, high availability and live migration are included. For storage you can use existing iSCSI or NFS storage, or the hosts’ own disks with ZFS or Ceph. There is a dedicated backup server, and paid support with a tested update repository is a subscription alongside the software.

Where Proxmox is strong: the software itself is free to use, it runs on almost any mainstream server, and you are not tied to one vendor. For a modest environment with a team or support partner that knows Linux, Proxmox vs VMware is often not a hard comparison.

What to watch: management needs Linux skills, and who you call at three in the morning has to be settled in advance. Check whether your backup software supports Proxmox at hypervisor level, or only through an agent inside every virtual machine; that makes a difference to restore speed and administration. And the richer features from the previous section (distributed networking, extensive automatic load balancing) exist in a different and often simpler form.

Hyper-V and Nutanix as VMware alternatives

Hyper-V is part of Windows Server. For an organisation that mainly runs Windows and already holds Windows Server licences, it is the alternative that needs the least new knowledge: failover clustering, live migration and replication to a second site are familiar ground. If you want compute and storage in the same hardware and management linked to Azure, look at Azure Local, the successor to Azure Stack HCI. Mind the tooling: management is spread across several consoles, which takes some getting used to after a single vCenter.

Nutanix provides a hyperconverged platform with its own hypervisor, AHV, which comes with the platform. Management sits in one environment and there is a dedicated migration tool that moves virtual machines across from VMware. The condition is that the hardware is on the list of supported configurations, so existing servers are not automatically reusable. More about the platform is on our Nutanix page.

There are more candidates, and moving to the public cloud is also an outcome. That is a different question with different costs, covered in the page on Azure, AWS or staying on VMware listed below.

Staying on VMware is also a choice

A migration costs time, skills and risk, and the alternative has to earn that back. Staying is reasonable if the environment is large and deeply tied to VMware (NSX, vSAN, replication with automated failover), if the hardware is due for replacement in a few years and you would rather combine the move with that, or if a key application is only supported on VMware.

Then do not compare this renewal with the alternative, but the coming years. On the VMware side, count every renewal over the whole period; on the other side, the licences or support of the alternative, the migration work, training, new backup software if the current one cannot follow, and the time during which two platforms run side by side.

If you stay, use the contract term to build the inventory from the earlier sections. Then the next renewal is a decision rather than a given.

Migrating in waves, with a way back

A VMware migration does not happen over one weekend. The order that works:

  • A pilot with virtual machines nobody will miss. A test server, a management server, a copy of something important. It shows how conversion behaves and whether backup and restore work before it matters.
  • Prepare at the source. Clear out snapshots, install the new platform’s drivers in Windows machines beforehand, and record which static IP addresses are in use. A new virtual network adapter in Windows often starts without the old address.
  • Waves by dependency. What belongs together moves together: an application with its database, and not your only domain controller at the same time as everything else. Each wave gets a maintenance window and an owner who tests.
  • A way back for every machine. Shut the source down, but only delete it once the new copy has been tested and accepted. It is the cheapest insurance in the whole project.
  • Only then tidy up. Decommission the old hosts, remove VMware tools from the virtual machines, update documentation and monitoring.

What is often forgotten in a migration

  • Licences inside the virtual machines. Windows Server is licensed on the physical cores of the hosts, regardless of the hypervisor. If the number or layout of hosts changes, recalculate. Software tied to a hardware identifier or a MAC address may ask to be reactivated after conversion.
  • Boot mode. A machine that boots with BIOS or UEFI has to arrive on the new platform the same way. The wrong setting gives a machine that will not start, and that looks like a failed conversion.
  • Storage performance. Measure beforehand what the busiest machines ask of storage. A new platform on the same disks behaves differently, especially when storage moves from a SAN to the hosts themselves.
  • Skills and procedures. Who runs it afterwards, with which runbooks, and what happens when the platform itself fails. An environment that only the migration partner understands is a new dependency.

Where our work stops

What we do. The inventory of what you use from VMware, the comparison of the alternatives against that list, the supply of servers and switches, the build of the new platform, the migration in waves and the management afterwards, including the backup alongside it. We deliver worldwide and have our own local engineers on site in every country.

What we do not do. We do not make the software: the hypervisor, its support and the licence terms come from VMware, Proxmox, Microsoft or Nutanix, and they decide what changes at renewal. We do not negotiate with a manufacturer on your behalf and we do not review licence agreements legally; that is work for a lawyer or a licensing specialist. And whether an application remains supported on another platform is for the vendor of that application to say, not us.

Frequently asked

Questions we get about this

The five that come up most often.

What is the best alternative to VMware?

It depends on what you use from VMware and who manages it. Proxmox suits a modest environment with Linux skills, Hyper-V an organisation that mainly runs Windows, and Nutanix those who want one hyperconverged platform with a manufacturer behind it. Start with the list of features you use; any alternative has to cover them.

Is Proxmox free, and is it ready for production?

The software is open source and free to use. Paid support with a tested update repository is a separate subscription, and for production that is the usual choice. Proxmox runs clusters with high availability and live migration; the condition is administration with Linux skills and an agreed point of contact for incidents.

How do you migrate virtual machines from VMware to Proxmox or Hyper-V?

With a conversion tool from the new platform or your backup software, in waves and after a pilot. Clear out snapshots first, install the new platform’s drivers in Windows machines and record static IP addresses. Only delete the source once the new machine has been tested and accepted.

Can we stay on VMware after the Broadcom acquisition?

Yes. The software works the same; what has changed is the licensing model, with subscriptions in bundles instead of standalone and perpetual licences. Staying is reasonable for a large, deeply integrated environment. Compare the coming years rather than just this renewal, and use the contract term to prepare an alternative.

Do you negotiate our licences with Broadcom?

No. We can buy licences for you and work out what a platform needs technically, but we do not negotiate with a manufacturer on your behalf and we do not review licence agreements legally. The terms and the support come from the manufacturer. We handle the inventory, the migration and the management.

Related services

Further reading

What the choice of a VMware alternative connects to.

Brands

The brands above, one page each

What the brand makes, which lines we supply and what we do around it.

Shall we set your VMware estate against the alternatives?

Send us what is running now and when your support ends. We will list which features you use, which alternative covers them and how a migration in waves would run.

Practical IT knowledge in your inbox

New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address for the newsletter only. See our privacy policy.

Request a quote Call