Request a quote
Emergency SectorsCareers About us Blog Get in touch
Two colleagues talking as they walk through a bright Amsterdam office, she with a laptop and he with a tablet, with canal houses through the windows

MDM vs MAM: the whole device, or only the work apps

MDM vs MAM is not a choice you make once for the whole organisation. Mobile device management controls the device; mobile application management controls only the apps that hold the work. Which one fits depends on who owns the device and what it needs to reach, and most organisations have more than one answer to both.

6 min read Written by the ITproposal team
Short answer

MDM manages the device: settings, apps, encryption and a full wipe. MAM protects only the work apps and their data, without enrolling the device.

Decide per device group: company phones get MDM, personal phones with work mail usually MAM, and a work profile sits in between.

MAM only works once the work environment refuses unprotected apps. Without conditional access, app protection is a suggestion.

MDM vs MAM: what each does and does not do

Mobile device management (MDM) enrols the device in your management platform. From then on you set the configuration: screen lock, encryption, wifi and VPN profiles, which apps are installed and which updates must be applied. If the device is lost, you wipe it completely. You also see what is out there: model, operating system, serial number.

Mobile application management (MAM) leaves the device alone and applies policy to the apps that hold the work, such as business mail, Teams and file storage. Those apps ask for a PIN, stop text and attachments being copied into personal apps, and can wipe their own work data without touching the user’s photos and messages. Microsoft calls this app protection in Intune, and it works without enrolling the device.

So the difference is not strong against weak but what you protect: the device or the data. That also decides what the user has to accept, and therefore whether they will.

What app protection cannot do

MAM is attractive because it is light, but it has limits worth knowing before you choose it:

  • No inventory. You know which protected apps are running, not which devices your organisation has.
  • No profiles. A wifi certificate for the staff network or a VPN profile reaches a device only through MDM.
  • No enforced updates. You can refuse access to an operating system that is too old, but you cannot install the update.
  • Only supported apps. A line-of-business app or an older business app without app protection support falls outside it.
  • No full wipe. On a stolen device you remove the work data, not the device.

On laptops the range of protected apps is much smaller and full management is the norm. This article is about phones and tablets.

The middle option: a work profile

Between full management and app protection alone there is a third option that is often overlooked. On Android, a personal device can get a work profile: a separate area with its own apps and data that you manage through MDM, while the personal side stays invisible and untouched. iPhone and iPad have something comparable in account-driven user enrolment, where work apps and data are kept apart and IT cannot wipe the device.

That is the option for a personal phone that needs more than mail: joining the staff network with a certificate, using an internal app without app protection support, or reaching internal systems over VPN. You get part of what MDM offers without taking over the whole device.

Which approach for which device

Most organisations do not have one kind of device but four or five. Put them side by side:

  • Company phone or tablet: MDM, ideally enrolled automatically through Apple Business Manager or Android zero-touch enrolment, so a device is managed from first boot. Add app protection on top.
  • Personal phone with work mail and Teams only: MAM. No enrolment, but the data in those apps is protected.
  • Personal phone that also needs internal systems: a work profile.
  • Shared devices, such as a warehouse scanner or a tablet at the till: MDM in a dedicated mode with a handful of apps.
  • Contractors and temporary staff: MAM, or browser access only, with an end date on the account.

Write that grouping down and give each group an owner. Without the list, every new device ends up configured however the person setting it up happens to prefer.

Enforcement: without conditional access it is a suggestion

App protection only covers the apps that receive the policy. If a user can add their work mailbox to the phone’s built-in mail app, an unprotected copy sits right next to it. The closing piece is conditional access: the work environment grants access only to apps with a protection policy, or to devices that are managed and compliant.

An order that works:

  • Run the policy in report-only mode first, so you see who would be refused without locking anyone out.
  • Start with a small group that includes someone from the leadership team, because those questions will come anyway.
  • Block the legacy sign-in methods that conditional access cannot see.
  • Then switch it on group by group, with a short note beforehand on what users will notice.

What IT can see, and telling people up front

With MDM on a company device, IT sees the model, operating system, serial number and installed apps, and can wipe the device. Messages, photos and browsing history are not part of that. With MAM on a personal device, IT sees only the protected apps and their work data. That difference is often exactly why people accept MAM on their own phone.

Put it in writing before you start: which approach for which device, what IT can and cannot see, and what happens when someone leaves. In the UK, the ICO’s guidance on monitoring workers expects employers to be open about this, and our article on BYOD in practice covers the policy side for personal devices.

And unified endpoint management?

Unified endpoint management (UEM) is the umbrella term for a single platform that manages phones, tablets and laptops. MDM and MAM are parts of it, not alternatives to it. Microsoft Intune is one example; most other management platforms offer the same building blocks.

For the decision that means one thing: the question is rarely which platform, but which approach per device group. If you already use Microsoft 365, the building blocks are often in your licence already. The work is in the grouping, the policies and the rollout.

Where our work stops

What we do. We draw up the grouping per device type, configure MDM, app protection, work profiles and conditional access, enrol the devices and keep the management running afterwards. That covers the devices, the licences and the configuration.

What we do not do. Mobile contracts, SIM cards, numbers and bundles stay with your network provider; we do not supply them. We are not lawyers or data protection officers either: what you tell staff about management and monitoring, and how your policy is worded, is your decision with your own advisers. We supply the facts about what the technology can and cannot see.

Frequently asked

Questions we get about this

The five that come up most.

What is the difference between MDM and MAM?

MDM manages the whole device: settings, apps, encryption, profiles and a full wipe. MAM manages only the work apps and their data, without enrolling the device. MDM protects the device, MAM protects the data.

Is MAM enough for personal phones?

For a personal phone used only for work mail, Teams and files, usually yes, provided conditional access refuses unprotected apps. If the phone also needs internal systems through a wifi certificate or VPN, a work profile is the better fit. Full MDM on a personal phone tends to meet resistance and is rarely necessary.

Can IT see my photos and messages with MDM?

No. With MDM, IT sees the model, operating system, serial number and installed apps, and can wipe the device. Messages, photos and browsing history are outside that. With MAM on a personal device, IT sees only the protected work apps.

Can you use MDM and MAM together?

Yes, and on company devices that is the normal setup. MDM manages the device and app protection controls on top of it what may happen with work data inside the apps. On personal devices you usually use MAM alone or a work profile.

Do you supply mobile contracts and SIM cards as well?

No. Contracts, SIM cards, numbers and bundles stay with your network provider. We supply the devices, the licences, the MDM and app protection setup, and the management afterwards.

Related services

Further reading

Where MDM and MAM connect.

Shall we sort your devices into groups?

Tell us which devices are in use and who owns them. We will propose which group gets MDM, which gets MAM, where a work profile fits, and the order to switch it on.

Practical IT knowledge in your inbox

New guides on management, security and the workplace, written by the people doing the work. No sales talk, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address for the newsletter only. See our privacy policy.

Request a quote Call